The UK’s Chancellor recently offered Britain’s pubs some relief on business rates in the Budget. But without fundamental tax reform, action on pub company ownership and stronger protection for community assets, the government risks presiding over the slow death of one of Britain’s most important social institutions.
Britain’s pubs are in trouble. Rising costs, large debts, squeezed household incomes and changing drinking habits have left thousands of pubs struggling to survive. Yet the latest Budget offers no comprehensive plan to secure their future. Instead, it provides some welcome relief on business rates while leaving the underlying economics of running a pub largely unchanged.
That is not a strategy: it is firefighting.
Our paper, Last orders? Pub closures, policy and the future of the public house in the UK, published in the journal Contemporary Social Science, argues that the crisis is about more than consumer preferences or failing businesses. It reflects a deeper contradiction in government policy. Politicians celebrate pubs as the heart of their communities while allowing taxation, ownership structures and property development incentives to undermine their survival.
The Budget does little to resolve that contradiction.
A sticking plaster, not a solution
The increase in business rates relief for qualifying pubs in England is welcome. The government estimates that the wider package will deliver average savings of more than £3,000 per pub next year, with additional smaller businesses becoming eligible for full relief.
For a struggling landlord, £250 a month can make a difference. It might pay an electricity bill, cover repairs or help retain a member of staff.
But the headline figures need perspective. Savings will vary between businesses, and the measures do not fully take effect until April 2027. More importantly, rates relief does not solve the wider squeeze on profitability.
Pubs still face rising wages, energy bills, insurance, food costs and alcohol duties. The National Living Wage is due to rise again in April 2027. Meanwhile, the Chancellor has declined to reduce the hospitality VAT rate.
A pub might save £3,000 on business rates while incurring substantially higher costs elsewhere. For some, the relief will be valuable. For others, it will merely offset part of the damage.
There is a further problem. Repeated adjustments to business rates are no substitute for a coherent, predictable system that recognises the particular economics of hospitality.
A more durable approach would build on the permanently lower hospitality multipliers already introduced by fundamentally reviewing how pubs’ rateable values are calculated and providing greater long-term certainty around pub-specific relief. The central problem is not simply the multiplier applied, but the interaction between valuation, taxation and the particular economics of running a pub.
The failure on VAT
The Chancellor’s refusal to cut hospitality VAT is an even bigger missed opportunity.
Pubs compete with supermarkets selling alcohol at prices they cannot match. They must cover premises, staffing and service costs through what customers spend on the premises, while supermarkets spread their costs across a much wider range of activities.
A reduction in hospitality VAT would not save every pub. Nor would every business pass the full saving on to customers. But it could provide room to lower prices, invest, employ staff, and rebuild margins.
The government needs to commission an urgent assessment of a phased reduction in hospitality VAT, examining the consequences for public finances alongside the potential benefits for employment, investment, and business survival.
If ministers believe that pubs have an important economic and social role, they need to explain why the tax system should continue to place such pressure on their ability to compete.
The problem is not simply that pubs are paying too much tax. It is that government policy fails to consider how different taxes and operating costs interact to determine whether a pub remains viable.
The problem is more than just tax.
Our paper identifies two deeper structural problems that business rates relief cannot fix.
The first is the financialisation and corporatisation of pub ownership. Where large pub companies (Pubcos) carry substantial debts, pressure to generate cash can take precedence over the long-term health of individual establishments. Tied tenants may face restricted purchasing choices, rents and other costs while carrying much of the commercial risk themselves.
The government should commission a comprehensive competition review of pub ownership and tenancy arrangements. It should examine whether tied agreements, purchasing restrictions and rent-setting arrangements create an unfair distribution of risk between pub companies and tenants.
Where the evidence identifies problems, ministers should strengthen the regulatory framework to promote fairer agreements, greater transparency and more viable trading conditions.
The second problem is what our paper calls the Prime Land Paradox: a pub may be worth more as a development site than as a functioning business.
In areas where property values are high, owners can have a powerful financial incentive to close a pub and sell the site for another use. The commercial value of the land can overwhelm the social value of the business operating on it.
No amount of tax relief will resolve that contradiction.
A more durable approach would be to strengthen planning protections against the loss of viable community pubs and require decisions on proposed conversions to take account of their wider local economic and social value.
This does not mean preventing every closure. Some pubs are no longer commercially viable, and property owners cannot reasonably be expected to operate businesses indefinitely at a loss. But the planning system should not make it unnecessarily easy to lose a valuable community asset simply because another use offers a higher financial return.
Pubs are social infrastructure. Government needs to recognise that.
Pubs are businesses, but they are also part of Britain’s social infrastructure. They provide places to meet, support local employment, host community activities and help sustain town centres and villages.
When the last pub closes, the consequences extend beyond the landlord and staff. Residents lose a place to socialise. Local organisations lose a venue. Other businesses can lose passing trade. In isolated communities, the loss can be particularly damaging.
These benefits are not fully reflected in the market price of a pub. Nor are they captured by the Treasury when calculating business rates or alcohol duty.
Our paper argues that the resulting losses are geographically unequal. Affluent areas may retain destination pubs, while poorer neighbourhoods and rural communities lose accessible places for everyday socialising. The emergence of these pub deserts is not simply a cultural change; it is a question of economic and social inequality.
The government could build on the existing Community Right to Buy Fund by creating a dedicated Community Pub Protection Fund, combining grants for community acquisition, support for cooperative ownership, and targeted assistance for pubs that provide demonstrable local benefits.
It could also introduce a Social Value Rate Relief scheme for qualifying pubs, prioritising the last pub in a village or neighbourhood and establishments in areas with limited alternative community facilities.
These interventions would recognise that a pub’s value cannot be measured solely by its profitability or the price someone might pay for its land.
Community ownership won’t work everywhere, and public money should not be used to prop up permanently unviable businesses. But where a pub can operate sustainably under community ownership, government should make it easier for residents to save it rather than watch it disappear.
Stop celebrating pubs while undermining them.
The Chancellor deserves some credit for providing additional business rates relief. But ministers cannot claim to be protecting Britain’s pubs while ignoring the wider forces driving closures.
A serious strategy would combine permanent business rates reform, a credible review of hospitality VAT, fairer pub tenancy arrangements, stronger planning protection and practical support for community ownership.
It would also measure success by outcomes rather than announcements: fewer avoidable closures, stronger independent businesses, more investment and communities retaining access to places to meet.
Not every pub can be saved. But government should distinguish between businesses that have genuinely lost their market and those undermined by a combination of policy choices, financial pressures and incentives that favour redevelopment over continued trading.
That requires more than warm words about the great British pub.
The government has a choice: either treat pubs as disposable businesses and development opportunities or recognise them as part of the country’s economic and social infrastructure and build policy accordingly.
The Budget has bought some pubs breathing space. It has not secured their future.
Without more fundamental reform, ministers may find themselves delivering another package of emergency relief while the communities that need their pubs most have already lost them.
And by then, sadly, it really would be last orders.
Read our paper here. Watch a video explanation here.
Listen to an Any Other Business Podcast about the paper here.
Connect with the Author

David Bailey is Professor of Business Economics at the Birmingham Business School, University of Birmingham, UK, and an ESRC ‘UK in a Changing Europe Senior Fellow’. He has written extensively on industrial and regional policy, especially in relation to manufacturing and the auto industry. He is Co-Editor-in-Chief of the journal Contemporary Social Science, editor of the journal Regional Studies, and a Director of the RSA Europe Think-Tank and policy forum. He has acted as a consultant for numerous organisations and companies. David is a regular media commenter and newspaper columnist.

Dieter F. Kogler is the Academic Director of the UCD Spatial Dynamics Lab and an Associate Professor in Economic Geography at the School of Architecture, Planning and Environmental Policy at University College Dublin. His research focuses on the geography of innovation and evolutionary economic geography, with particular emphasis on knowledge production and diffusion, as well as processes related to technological change, innovation, and economic growth. He is currently an ERC Starter Grant holder with the following project title: Technology Evolution in Regional Economies (TechEvo). In parallel, he also leads an SFI-funded Science Policy Research Program project on Science-Technology Spaces (SciTechSpace). Dieter is an Editor of Regional Studies and an Editorial Board member of the Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society.

Philip Tomlinson is a Professor of Industrial Strategy in the School of Management at the University of Bath. He is the Deputy Director of the Centre for Governance, Regulation & Industrial Strategy (CGR&IS) and he also works closely with the University of Bath’s Institute for Policy Research (IPR). His research has been received by the Department of Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS), Department for Transport, NESTA, Innovate UK, the TUC, Industry Trade Associations, and other business and regional organizations.